Using Islam to suppress Islam

| 4 Comments | No TrackBacks

Here's a report from Reuters about what sounds like an attempt by a secular government to use "Shari'ah" in order to suppress Islam (linked off Ginny's blog):

On 6 November, Tajik President Emomali Rahmonov made a decree banning women from mosques. "More than a thousand years of Islam's history, including the Sunni branch and, particularly, the doctrine of the Great Imam (Azam), says that it is preferred that women pray in solitude, in other words it is more favourable if they pray at home," Rahmonov said, justifying his decision.

Imam Azam, by the way, is Imam Abu Hanifa, radhi Allahu 'anhu (which is never pointed out in this piece; obviously the author doesn't know much about Islam).

This isn't the first time such a thing has happened, by the way - it was reported that the British attempted to "use Shari'ah" against Somali women during their occupation of northern Somalia. In fact, women not attending mosques is not demanded by Shari'ah, although it's never been encouraged for women to do their regular prayers in the mosque. Doing those in the home is vastly more meritorious; but what happens if the woman cannot pray at home because there is fighting, or it has been washed out in a flood and she needs a place to pray, or if she is in a different part of the city? If she can't use the mosque, she may have to use the park, which is even more exposed than the mosque.

But in the classical period in Baghdad and elsewhere, women did take and give lessons in the mosque, and major imams attended. Of course, they must observe proper hijab, but if she's giving lessons, she knows that anyway, doesn't she?

No TrackBacks

TrackBack URL: http://www.blogistan.co.uk/mt4/mt-tb.cgi/4339

4 Comments

Is it correct that the Ottoman Sultan Abd-al Hamid II used state Islam to maintain the empire's unity and territorial integrity, while implementing reforms which violated the Shari'ah ? Was he in fact not the reactionary fundamentalist portrayed in Western anti-Ottoman propaganda, but rather the 'Neil Kinnock' to Ataturk's 'Tony Blair'?

Interestingly enough the MWU pro-regressives have brought this up to maximize their claim that muslimas are rountinely banned from the masjid all over the world. Strange how those who dont even go to the masjid and discourage congregational salah are up in arms about this, dont you think ?
Methinks the munafiqs doth protest too much.

The traditional madhhab of Tajikistan is the Hanafi madhhab but the new Islamic/Revolutionary /Democratic opposition is inclined towards "re-interpretation".

Assalamu Alaykom,
Just wanted to draw yor attention that someone has posted some comments about pornographic sites under yor post about women and mosque attendance.
Aicha (a fellow NMP'er)

Leave a comment

Archives

OpenID accepted here Learn more about OpenID
Powered by Movable Type 4.2-en