The Independent reported a few days ago that a young woman was murdered in Gaza by members of Hamas, because she was seen walking in the streets with her husband. The story has been repeated in the New Zealand Herald after the Independent’s copy of its report went into pay-per-view. Bear in mind that the Independent is regarded as a left-wing and generally pro-Arab newspaper, and its best known columnist is Robert Fisk. So whatever can be said about the mainstream western media, I don’t think they’d issue an inauthentic story which shows Palestinians in as bad a light as this.
Except that it’s not Palestinians this reflects badly on, but Hamas - the report makes clear that locals are outraged, and that Hamas fear that the action may cost them dearly in upcoming elections. A Hamas spokesman is reported to have claimed that the killing was due to a “suspicion of immoral behaviour”, and the group has issued leaflets promising to punish the people responsible. Honour killings are a known problem in that part of the world, but this seems to be the first time it’s been carried out by members of an armed group (the report suggests that factionalism may be at work, as the victim was married to a Fatah member).
A guy called Patrick, posting at Clarity & Resolve and Pardon My English, calls this “a deliberate act of base depravity for Allah”. Well, as a Muslim all I can say is that there have been Muslims from the earliest days of Islam whose fanaticism leads them to exceed the bounds of decency. Anyone with an ounce of Islamic knowledge will tell you that you cannot kill someone for holding hands with someone of the opposite sex in public, especially if they are married! The death penalty, which is by stoning (not shooting), only applies to proven married adulterers - and proving it is no easy task. There is no sanction whatsoever for killing people for anything less than that, much less for the mere suspicion of it.
I intend, insha Allah, to obtain word from various Islamic authorities on the status of this killing (this takes time). From what I’ve read, it’s just plain murder.
(And what is PME doing on Google News? I thought Google News was for news, not blogs.)
Possibly Related Posts:
- Robert Spencer, Patrick Sookhdeo and me
- KFC and the BNP
- Dentists as moral arbiters
- Fitz says kick Muslims out of Europe
- Spencer, the NDU scholars, the securocrat and his books