How racist is Britain?

How racist is Britain? Julian Baggini on why he doesn’t believe most white Britons are racists - even though he heard racist language almost everywhere he went (from today’s Guardian)

This was in the Guardian today, and follows the author when he lived for six months in Rotherham in south Yorkshire. What he found was that local white and Asian people saw little of each other and that white people commonly called the Asians “Pakis” without apparently intending it as a term of abuse, but rather as “simply a matter-of-fact description of the ethnic origins” of the person referred to.

The article barely touches on the fact that Asians as well as whites use the term, but does not show anything of the extent to which they do. In some sections of the Asian community, particularly among the younger generation, the term is used quite commonly and certainly not as an insult, and a similar term “Guji” exists to mean Gujarati. I was once in a British Pakistani friend’s house and was eating his mother’s food (lots of it) with a Gujarati convert to Islam from Jainism. Referring to the food, he said “I wasn’t cut out to be a Paki”, meaning to eat so much! Nobody took the slightest offence. When my friend said that he was “an English Paki, not a Paki Paki”, his mother did reprimand him though.

I wouldn’t compare it to the “N word”, even though some black Americans have “reclaimed” that term, and even though it’s just a corruption of the Spanish for black, because it has a much longer history and carries particular offence for some people. Even so, I’ve got the impression that some people think they can avoid being offensive simply by avoiding dropping the “N word”; a notable example being Roger Roots’ infamous Hundred Facts and One Lie pamphet which likened black people to apes over and over again, “backing it up” with citations which actually mostly traced back to pro-segregation and otherwise racist tracts. He didn’t use the “N word” either.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

Possibly Related Posts:


FacebookTwitterIdenti.caDeliciousDiggStumbleUponWordPressShare
CommunityPermalink
  • aya

    I hate the word ‘paki’ because, like the ‘N’ word, it was intended to be a racist term.

    The excuse Pakistanis use today is extraordinay. They say, “It’s ok, we don’t mean it in a racist way. We can use it, but they can’t.”

    SubhanAllah! What, did Allah (swt) Allow different races to use words that others are banned from? Did He favour people over others in this way? Their argument is stupid, and it’s akin to ‘white-only’ water-fountains or restaurants in america before the civil rights movement took force. ‘Coz, “hey guys, if you can have a Pakistani-only word, we can have a white-only school!”

    Not only that, the ‘P’ word provides mental subjugation. Sound very strange, yet it is very true. As ‘pakis’, asian boys wanna be gangstas, and asian girls wanna be tarts, but as pakistanis, they are much more respectful.

    Seriously, try this out. Next time a family member starts doing something stupid say “stop it, you’re a Pakistani!” and compare that with “stop it, you’re a paki!” The differences will be amazing.

    Finally, I take HUGE offense at the word ‘paki’, and so do many, many other people. And from surat-al-hujurat, verse 11, I think it’s safe to conclude that one should just totally stop using it.

    Jzk

    wa’laykum assalaam

  • Old Pickler

    Depends on the context, the tone of voice, and the relationship of the people saying the word to each other.

    The UK is racist, yes, but far less racist than just about any other country you can think of.

    (And we’re a lot less xenophobic than those rotten foreigners.)

  • DrM

    Were you trying to be sarcastic, pRickler?

  • Old Pickler

    Never.

  • M Risbrook

    Pakistan, literally means the land of the Pakis in the same way that Uzbekistan means the land of the Uzbeks, and Tajikistan means the land of the Tajiks. An Uzbek would refer to somebody from Pakistan as a Paki and not a Pakistani.

    The real origin of the name Pakistan is a contraction of Punjab, Afghania, Kashmir, Sind, and Balochistan devised by a student at Cambridge university during the 1930s and originally known as Pakstan. The i was added later to make it more pronounceable.

  • john

    if britain is such a racist country why do thousands of people flock here every year???? Also if people feel that britain is such a good place to live why try and change it?? AS for the “N” word i have heard blacks call each other it for years and the word paki isnt on the scale of things really something to get bent out off shape about it….? There is far more other things going on in the country that in my opinion need to be sorted out first rather than worring about name calling. As a white christian hetrosexaul its people like me who are being victimised on a daily bases our rights and freedoms are being eroded away. All other minorites are being given prefernce over us including gays and lesbians,muslims,jews,blacks…..do i need go on. this country was founded on christian beliefs but we are being forced into being a minority. It all very well saying that britain has to be diverse thats true up to a point. i was reading a paper on the net yesterday saying that gay police should police gay areas i was shocked by this on the same token should straight police patrol all the other areas of britain????? just a example of britain being a crappy place to live

  • Yaser

    @m.risbrook

    you’ve kinda contradicted yourself . . as ‘Pakstan’ equates to ‘land of the pure’ with ‘stan’ being the Farsi suffix for land. You’ve mentioned the i being added for easier pronounciation and the the connotations in Britain with ‘Paki’ are none too pleasant.

  • http://www.developingdivorcee.blogspot.com pserean

    john… im sorry to be the one to tell you this, but im afraid you’re paying for the sins of youre forefathers. * heartfelt sigh* if they hadnt insisted on colonising half the world with brute unbridled force…the natives probably wouldnt have taken it into their heads to check out your country, see what all the fuss is about…and maybe wreak some amusing vengeance by opening up curry stores on every corner.

    as for the gays..you can always try exiling them to lesbos island sorry (i truly empathise on this one…) .-= pserean´s last blog ..Spectator Support… Who’s got the remote control? =-.