Niqaabs for Afghanistan?

Having just watched a More 4 documentary of Malalai Joya, the woman who was elected to the Afghani parliament after getting thrown out of the Loya Jirga for standing up to condemn warlords, it struck me that she wore the notorious Afghan burqa, which she said she disliked, to conceal her identity and encouraged other women who were in danger to do the same.

Why has nobody thought to introduce the niqab to that country? I understand that some will not exactly see it is a huge leap for women’s liberation, but a woman can easily pull up a niqab to show her face without showing the rest of her front, she can uncover her eyes or else choose between two levels of eye covering. You don’t get any of this choice with the burqa, quite apart from the cumbersomeness of the garment itself and, doubtless, the heating cheap fabric used in it. I wonder why it persists when a vastly more practical method of covering the face exists?

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

Possibly Related Posts:


FacebookTwitterIdenti.caDeliciousDiggStumbleUponWordPressShare
Muslim world, WomenPermalink
  • dawud

    short answer? a preference for their culture over fiqh or dispensations from other traditions. wa Allahu alim

  • Thersites

    Anyone who puts on niqab instead of a burka would be recognisable because no-one- or hardly anyone- else did. Equally they would perceived as innovative and wicked because to certain ways of thinking innovation and wickedness are synonymous; unless it’s a new improved weapon, of course.

  • Dom

    Why are muslims so obsessed with women’s headwear? School-girls are incinerated alive because they don’t have scarves on, a woman’s stoning is temporarily interrupted to re-cover her head, and so on. It’s just hair, guys. Don’t you have personal hygiene problems of your own to worry about?

  • http://www.drmaxtor.blogspot.com DrM

    Incineration and stoning? Put down your crack pipe, Dom. Put down the Sun, or whatever tabloid rag you’re high on. The better question is why are non-Muslim males so obsessed with Muslim womans clothing? Sounds like a mental disorder amongst ignorant pervs.

  • Dom

    The case of the young school girls is fairly well known.

    http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/1874471.stm

    And any number of religious leaders have given pronouncements on how to handle a stoning victim if her hood comes undone.

  • http://www.liquescent.net/blog M. Landers

    For whatever it’s worth, the materials choices for niqab/khimar/abaya sets and afghan-style burqa/chadri/chador (or whatever it’s being called these days) are about the same, some better and some worse. Since neither niqab nor burqa are worn without full undergarments, and burqas are open to the front, both are just as easy to flip back away from the face when appropriate without exposing the body. In short, there has been no mass adoption of the niqab simply because there is no need — it does not have any greater level of practicality than any open-style abaya, and on an aesthetic level personally I would prefer the fine embroidery and lighter colors traditional to the Afghan style than what is more typically seen of niqab. Were I living where the garment was a normative option I’d be hard pressed to want to trade it in on your suggestion myself — each have advantages and disadvantages, but neither is by nature a nightmare or reprieve in comparison to the other.

  • Indigo Jo

    As-Salaamu ‘alaikum

    The materials used in niqaab vary hugely; there is a particular type used in the Gulf, which many serious niqaabis in the west favour as well, which uses a soft cotton layer next to the face and uses material for the eye layer which is easy to see through. Also, the niqab is worn with a garment which is either buttoned closed at the front or else without a front opening at all, so the wearer does not have to hold it shut, and as much as needed can be exposed without opening the whole thing at the front. I agree that a lot of both Afghan burqas and niqaabs are made of rubbish fabric, but the niqab is much more versatile from what I’ve observed.