Don’t kill the fattened calf for Ed & co

An unusually perceptive Ziauddin Sardar finally delivers a dissenting view of the media’s lionising of “Sir Edward Husain” and his clique in today’s Guardian, on the grounds that it ignores those who always resisted falling into the hands of the extremists:

The embrace of former extremists is a slap in the face for Muslims who have worked tirelessly to build a British Muslim identity and foster inclusion by constructive community activity. It’s another attempt at the marginalisation of the overwhelming majority who never had a moment’s doubt that Islam gives no sanction for such murderous and misguided perversion of belief.

I am troubled by the fact that former extremists are seen as the only people who know how to deal with extremism. Just because you have been an inmate of a mental hospital does not mean you are an expert in clinical psychology. But former extremists are being lionised because they confirm the basic tabloid prejudice that violence is a natural part of being a Muslim. So whose ignorance is being vindicated? Certainly the potential of an open, unapologetic belief in Islam as a valuable part of British society is not on the agenda.

FacebookTwitterIdenti.caDeliciousDiggStumbleUponWordPressShare
Posted in Ed Husain, Shiraz Maher, ZiaWatch | 2 Comments

What don’t people get about Ed Husain?

Technorati Tags: , ,

On Monday, the Guardian printed an abridgement of Andrew Anthony’s response to David Edgar’s piece in the Guardian Review about the recent fad for “defection literature”, amongst which he lists Nick Cohen, Andrew Anthony himself, Ed Husain and Melanie Phillips whom he says “wears the ‘apostate’ label with pride”. Andrew Anthony writes:

The key name, here I think, is that of Ed Husain.

If you can really view someone who leaves an imperialist, anti-semitic, anti-democratic, ultra-religious party like Hizb ut-Tahrir and comes out in favour of democracy and religious tolerance as a defector moving rightwards, then it shows your political - not to mention, moral - compass is in urgent need of repair.

Continue reading

FacebookTwitterIdenti.caDeliciousDiggStumbleUponWordPressShare
Posted in Ed Husain, Shiraz Maher | 1 Comment

London election is not just about race

The recent issue of Red Pepper contains an editorial, written by Oscar Reyes, about the upcoming mayoral elections in London. Reyes notes that Boris Johnson, the Tory challenger for the position against Labour’s Ken Livingstone, has hired the Australian strategist Lynton Crosby, who is known for running divisive “dog whistle” campaigns for the “Liberals” in his home country, winning them several elections, and trying the same for the Tories in the UK in 2005, when they lost handily. Johnson has also been much assisted by the London Evening Standard, which has run one front-page after another about what they presume readers will think his nasty friends, which last week were the Muslim Brotherhood and today the Sikh Federation UK.

Continue reading

FacebookTwitterIdenti.caDeliciousDiggStumbleUponWordPressShare
Posted in London life, Politics | 4 Comments

Government puts trust in moderate foreign imams

Smith invites moderate imams into UK to help Muslim communities fight extremism (from the Guardian)

Jacqui Smith, the new Home Secretary, proposes to invite moderate foreign imams (from the Indian Subcontinent) in an apparent attempt to fight extremism in the UK. The report mostly focusses on new anti-terrorist police jobs and kicking foreign terrorism suspects out, so there is not much room for discussing where these moderate figures are to come from, as in which institutions in the home countries.

I always thought that common thinking on the subject was that foreign imams were the problem, not the solution? Many of these imams do not speak English, at least not enough to deliver a meaningful sermon, much less personal guidance, and the proportion of Muslims in this country of Subcontinental descent who speak good Urdu has declined over the years (to say nothing of those who never spoke Urdu to begin with). The presence of imams whose English is not sufficient, or who choose not to use it “for the sake of the old folk”, shuts out people who do not speak the language they use, which includes converts as well as immigrants from other Muslim countries. Meanwhile, the extremists and sectarians are only too willing and able to use English.

Surely the solution is to employ more British-born scholars as imams, whether they be trained in the Middle East or in the Subcontinent, while maintaining agreements with the governments in those countries to allow them to stay rather than kicking them out after every “security” (or security PR) panic. Perhaps also, religious institutions in the UK should be supported (they do not need to be founded anew, as was the Maynooth Catholic seminary in Ireland, founded by the British to dissuade Irish Catholics from going to Europe to study). This way, we end up with a form of religion which is relevant to the average Muslim in this country, rather than only to the Asians, or just some of them.

FacebookTwitterIdenti.caDeliciousDiggStumbleUponWordPressShare
Posted in Islam | 14 Comments

A13, trunk road to … where?

Wi-fi cameras to track drivers’ average speed | News (from Evening Standard)

Today, the Evening Standard reported that a new wi-fi-based speed camera system is to be tried out along the A13, the main road out of London to the east, between Canning Town and the Goresbrook interchange, which is the start of the new A13 relief road across the marshes; this means all of the old A13 between the end of the Docklands tunnels and the start of the Dagenham by-pass. The BBC, in their reporting of the story (they covered it in their London drive-time show), clarified that the scheme was not going to result in any fines, but was just a trial of the system.

Continue reading

FacebookTwitterIdenti.caDeliciousDiggStumbleUponWordPressShare
Posted in Road Life | 1 Comment

Racism or just commercial sense?

The other week, I prepared a post about the controversy caused by the singer Estelle, whose song was top of the UK singles charts a couple of weeks ago, alleging that the singers being pushed as soul in the UK (which I don’t think they are) not being real soul artists (which they are not), and it being all too easy for white singers to get noticed by the media making black music in the UK, but black artists have to go to America. In her case, going to America got her the services of John Legend and Kanye West, so I do not know what she was complaining about, but the comments by Noel Gallagher that Jay-Z was the wrong person to be the headliner at Glastonbury this summer has reignited the controversy about racism in music.

Continue reading

FacebookTwitterIdenti.caDeliciousDiggStumbleUponWordPressShare
Posted in Arts | 2 Comments

Sister Ardo responds to “Blog Niqaab”

Sister Ardo from Ottawa (whom you may remember contributed to my coverage of the Jack Straw niqaab affair of 2006) has responded to sister Aaminah’s article on observing niqaab while interacting with others over the internet, as a reminder of Islamic etiqutte. She talks about why she took up the niqaab and the enticements to remove it. (As an aside, sister Aaminah’s article was not the first time I have heard the argument about niqaab as a physical reminder about Islamic behaviour; I wonder how that works for us men, though.)

FacebookTwitterIdenti.caDeliciousDiggStumbleUponWordPressShare
Posted in Niqab (face-covering) | 7 Comments

The violent face of evangelical Anglicanism

New Statesman - Fundamental change

This week’s New Statesman has a feature on resurgent religion, particularly evangelical Anglicanism but also Catholicism, including a lengthy interview with the Bishop of Durham. The article I’ve featured here is about Evangelicals “infiltrating” parishes in order to convince local people to be stronger in their religion. Scary stuff. Also, the writer is shocked that their litmus test for orthodoxy is opposition to ordaining practising gay men as priests, something that would have been unthinkable only a generation ago. Really, don’t these people understand that the US Episcopal church is the laughing stock of the country’s Protestant community and an outsider even within the Anglican communion?

Continue reading

FacebookTwitterIdenti.caDeliciousDiggStumbleUponWordPressShare
Posted in Religion | 6 Comments

The torch’s progress

So, the Olympic torch has made its brief visit to London over the weekend, with a trip across London from west (Wembley) to east (Stratford, where it passed by the 2012 building site) and down south (the former Millennium Dome, which is on the southern bank but is on a bit of the south side that pokes up north) before heading off to Paris for an equally eventful progress through that city. I’m personally in two minds about all this - I’m glad that people have tried to turn the relay into a rally, but don’t really object to the Olympics being in Beijing as, if a country’s human rights record was a bar to the country holding a sporting event, the Olympics would never get held anywhere. After all, once all the third world countries are eliminated, it might occur to the committee who decides that the third-world countries that got eliminated were clients of at least one of the western countries that weren’t.

However, I do object to the extent to which this government goes to appease the Chinese authorities. Last weekend, the torch was accompanied by a set of Chinese guards in blue, and the point of the Chinese presence was that they spoke Chinese - presumably so that they could identify protesters with the wrong Chinese slogans. When the country’s president, Jiang Zemin, visited a few years ago, this government also bent over backwards to make sure that he didn’t see too much of the demonstration, including (according to one letter in the Guardian) making sure the police cleared protesters off a bridge over Jiang’s route. Clearly it wouldn’t impress a quasi-dictator to see a demonstrator against him on a foreign visit, even to a country he knew to be a democracy, but what are they going to do - stop selling us computer parts or (perish the thought) zips for our trousers?

One other thought: I was wondering why the torch wasn’t taken out to Shropshire as well, given that the original Olympics of modern times were, and still are, held in the village of Much Wenlock in that county. Perhaps it was down to time (although the Chinese are apparently finding time to get a torch - albeit not the torch, but one lit from the same flame - up Mount Everest), but surely they will make time for this in 2012, when the modern Olympics, like football in 1996, “come home”?

FacebookTwitterIdenti.caDeliciousDiggStumbleUponWordPressShare
Posted in Sport | 7 Comments

Jury rejects conspiracy theories about Lady Diana

BBC NEWS: Princess Diana unlawfully killed

An inquest jury in London has found that the late Lady Diana, Princess of Wales, and her lover Emad “Dodi” Fayed, son of Mohamed al-Fayed, was unlawfully killed due to the “gross negligence” of their driver and the press photographers who were pursuing them, and added that the way they were being driven, and their failure to wear seat-belts, contributed to their deaths.

Continue reading

FacebookTwitterIdenti.caDeliciousDiggStumbleUponWordPressShare
Posted in News | 4 Comments

Snow in April!

Well, it doesn’t snow that often in England anyway, but snow in April is really unusual (though I’ve witnessed snow in Spring in the past, in the early 1990s when I was at boarding school in Suffolk) particularly when it’s been warm during the past week. Waking up this morning, I heard it on the news that there was a jam on the M4 (the motorway from London to south Wales) and they said it started out at Hungerford, which made me think “oh, there’s snow out in the downs in west Berkshire” - but then they said “to junction 1 at Chiswick”, and I thought, “what, that means there really is snow here”, and I looked out of my bedroom window and there it was. It’s not Canadian weather, and it was all gone by early afternoon so there wasn’t much to take pictures of when I was finally able to get out, but I got a couple of pictures of it anyway. (One of them is private, as it shows the view from my bedroom window, so you will only see it if you are my friend.)

Also, you can see on my Flickr page a couple of pictures of my new car, or rather, the new family car which I have the most use of. It’s a little Daewoo Matiz with a 1-litre engine, so it’s no speed demon but it will get me to work quicker than the train will (although I will probably continue to use the bus or train within town because it saves having to park). I went out to Boxhill last Thursday so I could take some shots of it somewhere other than outside the house, as I don’t want the whole world and his wife knowing where I live, but my initial idea of parking in the car park and taking a walk around was thwarted when I discovered that Boxhill has a flat-rate £3 parking charge. So I had to park on the Zig Zag, and I had forgotten what the views along that road are like, which sort of made the frustration worth it.

So, here are the pictures. (More: iMuslim.)

FacebookTwitterIdenti.caDeliciousDiggStumbleUponWordPressShare
Posted in London life | 6 Comments

Test again

Test again

FacebookTwitterIdenti.caDeliciousDiggStumbleUponWordPressShare
Posted in Admin, Media | Leave a comment

What use is the semicolon?

Apparently, according to some French writers, not much - according to this article, very few modern French writers use it, and the decline in its use is due to the invasion of British usages which are “too direct” to make use of the supposed subtlety of the semicolon. The only problem is that many English writers themselves make use of it - having just gone over my own main page I find several of them.

How is the semicolon too subtle for English, then? The purpose of it is to demonstrate a connection between one phrase and another, both of which qualify as sentences in themselves, that is stronger than that between two separate sentences. Perhaps that’s subtle, but not too subtle that it’s beyond the reach of anyone who wants to be a serious writer to understand, when it really is a very useful, even important, piece of grammar?

I’ve long been pretty conservative when it comes to matters of the English language (as here), but I find the attitude of some of those quoted as being against it, both French and English-speaking, rather off-putting. If people don’t find it useful in their writing, they are quite at liberty not to use it, but they should not dismiss it as reflecting “a fuzziness of thought” or just that you’ve been to college. (Actually, I’m pretty sure I used them before I went to college, but I do remember asking my teacher about semicolons when I was 7 or 8 and being told we did not use them in that year.) Do people really hate their English or French teachers that much that they deprive themselves of a way of expressing themselves in writing, let alone want to deprive others?

FacebookTwitterIdenti.caDeliciousDiggStumbleUponWordPressShare
Posted in Language | 3 Comments

How sincere is Hassan Butt?

The last couple of weeks there has been a controversy over a new book being co-written by Hassan Butt, former al-Muhajiroun activist and self-proclaimed terrorist fixer and fundraiser, and the British writer and “journalist” Shiv Malik. The two were hoping to tell the world about Butt’s exploits in Pakistan after the 9/11 atrocities; the police had other ideas, and demanded that Malik hand over the unfinished manuscript. Nick Cohen hailed the two as “persecuted peacemakers” in this article for the Observer the Sunday before last. Some of us, however, are not so convinced by Butt’s turn-around.

Continue reading

FacebookTwitterIdenti.caDeliciousDiggStumbleUponWordPressShare
Posted in Ed Husain, Shiraz Maher, Extremism, Shiv Malik, Terrorism | 1 Comment

The Middle-Eastern heritage of South Shields

The Guardian: Less Cookson, more Ali: Tyneside town finds hidden Muslim history

The Guardian today printed this feature on the history of South Shields, a town in the conurbation of Newcastle in England, which has a history of settlement by Yemenis going back to the 19th century when an Arab sailors’ boarding house was opened there (and there were Arab soldiers in the area during Roman times as well, from Iraq of all places, helping to guard Hadrian’s Wall). The town’s mosque was where the boxer Muhammad Ali held his religious marriage, on a visit to support a local boxing club. However, a pleasantly interesting part was how integrated the community became:

[Tina Gharavi, director of a film about Muhammad Ali’s visit] said the most striking thing about the Muslim community was how peacefully integrated it had become. “It’s hard to make a film about nothing happening but that’s the truth, not much has happened because the integration has been successful. They are the first Muslim settled community in Britain and there were a few letters to the paper, but when you follow and read the discussions it was all about integration. Local women were marrying Yemenis and they were saying it was because they didn’t drink and they made good husbands. There’s certainly not a debate about the fact that they are Muslims.

While I’m not suggesting that all Muslim men today should follow these sailors’ examples, it’s nice that they were known (back in the dark ages!) as good husbands - unlike some yobs from Algeria who were busted in Finsbury Park last week for running a criminal empire out of a street near there, who were known for harrassing “unsuitably dressed” women. However, the community also spread to Cardiff, and the imam at one of the mosques in the Cardiff Bay district is (or was, in 2000 when I visited) of Yemeni origin (his daughters married in Yemen) and comes from Newcastle. It’s one of the most pleasant and peaceful mosques I’ve ever prayed in.

FacebookTwitterIdenti.caDeliciousDiggStumbleUponWordPressShare
Posted in Community | 1 Comment

The real Fitna

I’ve watched Geert Wilders’s new film Fitna. I am sure nobody expects a good write-up of it from me, but it’s a really poor piece of film. (More: HAhmed, Austrolabe, reproduced at Muslim Matters, CLOSER which examines the Dutch newspaper headlines reproduced in Fitna.)

Continue reading

FacebookTwitterIdenti.caDeliciousDiggStumbleUponWordPressShare
Posted in Reviews | 17 Comments

Idiotic response to a positive proposal

Five Chinese Crackers covers the tabloid response to the recent NUT faith education proposal. I did start writing a piece after reading the Guardian’s write-up of it, by which account it seems to be a reasonable and moderate proposal, but didn’t read the Express’s website or the Mail’s coverage. The Spew not only used the headline “Koran to be taught in schools”, as if it were going to be taught in all schools to everyone, but they titled their on-line “Have Your Say” page on the subject “Should imams teach our children?” and accompanied it with a scarily-lit picture of Abu Hamza.

Continue reading

FacebookTwitterIdenti.caDeliciousDiggStumbleUponWordPressShare
Posted in Education, Media | 2 Comments

Omar Bakri expresses dim view of Amir Khan

Today’s Sun (Murdoch-owned London tabloid) led with a front-page story about something Omar Bakri said about Amir Khan. Omar Bakri is the former leader of the disbanded al-Muhajiroun, who ran noisy demonstrations and street-corner stalls until they were banned in 2005; Amir Khan is a British Pakistani boxer. Apparently, “in an internet exchange with other extremists”, Omar Bakri said that Khan was jahil, meaning ignorant:

Asked if Amir was setting a bad example by draping himself in the flag, he replied: “I don’t think somebody should really look to Amir Khan as a good example for the youth.

“So now for him to be wrapping himself in British flag is another sign of somebody who is completely jahil. You give him the excuse of ignorance for living among the kuffar. So you can’t call him kuffar but you can call him jahil and deviant person.”

Continue reading

FacebookTwitterIdenti.caDeliciousDiggStumbleUponWordPressShare
Posted in Extremism, Media, Windbags | 2 Comments

Tobacco display ban: beyond the easy parodies

Over the weekend the government announced that it was considering banning the open display of cigarettes for sale, as is commonly found in any tobacco shop, whether a local corner shop or a supermarket. This would apply not only to over-the-counter cigarettes but also vending machines.

Now, I think this is a really good idea, and I would go further: get rid of brands of cigarette altogether. Just have generic cigarettes or tobacco for rolling, with no flavourings, no vanilla or menthol or anything else (an alternative, which I heard suggested several years ago, is to give all the brands stupid names like “jerk”). Advertising of tobacco products was rightly banned several years ago, because what it does - raise awareness of the availability of tobacco - is harmful. The open display of branded packets of cigarettes and cigars are the last bastion of tobacco advertising.

Continue reading

FacebookTwitterIdenti.caDeliciousDiggStumbleUponWordPressShare
Posted in Media, News | 3 Comments

Who are the “Scargills of Islam”, then?

Charles Moore, well-known writer for the Telegraph and Spectator and known among us for articles like this one from 2005, calling for the Muslims to bring forward a Gandhi (my response here), gave a lecture to the Centre for Policy Studies Monday before last entitled “How to beat the Scargills of Islam”. Arthur Scargill was the leader of the miners’ union in the early 1980s who led a major, but unsuccessful, strike against coal mine closures; he is a byword, at least among British conservatives, for intransigent and unreasonable trade union behaviour. Moore’s proposition appears to be that many of the alleged leaders of the Muslims in the UK today, like Scargill, have serious flaws in their legitimacy. You can read the lecture here (PDF) and an article based on it in the Spectator here.

Continue reading

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

FacebookTwitterIdenti.caDeliciousDiggStumbleUponWordPressShare
Posted in Media, Organisations & Leadership | 1 Comment