Letter to the Guardian on Niqaab

A picture of a white woman wearing a light-coloured headscarf and face coveringI wrote this letter last Thursday after seeing a series of very hostile letters in the Guardian following Kira Cochrane’s article in which she interviewed women who wear the niqaab (who had been conspicuously absent from the discussion up until then) which was published last Tuesday. They included a particularly ludicrous letter (last Wednesday) which compared wearing niqaab in the UK to sitting at a cafe in Saudi Arabia dressed in “full crusader regalia”, the equivalence of female civilian clothing with male military uniform demonstrating a clear refusal to distinguish ordinary Muslims from terrorists:

Continue reading

Possibly Related Posts:


A suspected war criminal to settle a hostage crisis?

Picture of a black man holding a machete, standing in front of a burning building.The BBC just reported that the trial at the Hague of William Ruto, the Kenyan deputy president, for crimes committed after the 2007 general election, has been suspended so that he can go back and deal with the crisis at the Westgate shopping centre, in which Somali militants have already murdered some 60 people and there are still hostages and others missing. His lawyer, Karim Khan, argued that Ruto had a duty to be present and the BBC correspondent said that nobody in court had any objection. Ruto is accused of plotting to establish militias and encouraging his supporters to “uproot weeds”, i.e. people of other ethnic groups to his.

This is hardly the sort of person you want in charge when the country is facing a hostage crisis: it has huge potential for a criminal response, anything from a repeat of the ending to the Moscow cinema siege (in which hostages as well as terrorists) were killed by the gas the police pumped into the building) or other hasty response, to reprisals against Somalis (and possibly other Muslims) in Kenya, particularly those in Nairobi itself. There is no guarantee that the Kenyans will send Ruto back to the Hague once this crisis is over, or they might claim that there is an “ongoing crisis” and never send him back, much as dictators the world over use “emergencies” to justify repression over decades. The last thing that needs to happen at a time like this is to put a man indicted for war crimes who thinks of people who are different to him as weeds.

Possibly Related Posts:


Coalition is not “Britain’s new normal”

Coalition Governing Could Be Britain’s New Normal Despite Liberal Democrats’ Troubles (from the New York Times)

This article claims that the “successful” Tory-Liberal Democrat coalition that was formed after the 2010 election has changed British attitudes to coalitions, which it says we previously “associated coalition governments with the unstable, revolving-door politics sometimes seen in Continental Europe”. It quotes one Professor Tim Bale of Queen Mary, University of London, as saying:

All the dire warnings given before the general election, particularly by the Conservatives and by the press, about a coalition being chaotic and messy and making Britain ungovernable do not seem to have come true … Most people appear to accept that it could become the new normal.

It also says that relations within the coalition are “civilized”, in contrast with the previous Labour government “when officials were prone to feuding”. Both Paddy Ashdown (from the Lib Dems) and Kenneth Clarke, “a centrist Conservative cabinet minister”, admit that their views had been changed as a result of being in the coalition, the latter saying that the Tories “have delivered more than we probably could have delivered as a single party in government”.

Continue reading

Possibly Related Posts:


Outbreak of media splaining over niqaab

A page from the Sun, showing a picture of a woman in niqaab along with blurbs on how veiling is practised (if at all) in France, Turkey, Egypt, Afghanistan, Syria, Egypt, Malaysia, Saudi Arabia, Indonesia and Canada.The recent wave of media interest in niqaab that resulted from the Birmingham College and niqaab-in-court affairs has, as previously noted, featured a lot of opinionising from almost everyone except for wearers — plenty of white men, a smattering of women and even a few Muslim women, but hardly any of them wear niqaab. Finally, Kira Cochrane in the Guardian and the UK Huffington Post got round to interviewing some, but the chorus of know-it-alls expounding on what the niqaab symbolises (to them) continues apace, along with tabloid demands to do things that are already being done anyway (for example, it’s already up to employers to decide what employees can wear when facing the public, never mind letting them wear the niqaab (not that I’ve ever been served by a woman in niqaab, even in a Muslim bookshop). Yesterday (Monday), Jeremy Vine yet again featured Taj Hargey explaining how the niqaab is supposedly not of Islamic origin, while the Sun lectured us about what really goes on in Muslim countries, where other than in Saudi Arabia, it’s either rare or banned. There’s a term used on some social justice blogs — “splaining” — meaning patronisingly or presumptuously “explaining” things from a privileged outsider’s perspective that they know very well from an insider’s one, and this behaviour is commonly found any time there is a “debate” to be had about this issue. Continue reading

Possibly Related Posts:


No basis for attack on niqaab

The front page of the Sun from tomorrow, calling for so-called vital reforms on niqabMy veil epiphany | Victoria Coren Mitchell | Comment is free | The Observer

Last Thursday a major further education college in Birmingham, the Birmingham Metropolitan College, backed down on a decision to ban face-coverings, including the niqaab worn by some Muslim women, after protests from the NUS Black students’ organisation and from a Muslim women’s group which called the ban “disproportionate” given the supposedly few wearers (there are actually a great many wearers in Birmingham, as well as other parts of the Midlands). I received a number of appeals to sign a petition opposing the ban, both from Muslim friends and others (particularly feminists); the petition gathered 8,000 signatures and a protest was planned for Friday, by which time the policy had already been reversed. This week, a judge also allowed a Muslim woman to appear in court without removing her veil (she showed her face to a female police officer who then affirmed her identity). Her barrister argued that there is no law in the UK on the niqaab and no rules prohibiting wearing it in court. It is she who is on trial for intimidating a witness, but her name has no far not been revealed.

Continue reading

Possibly Related Posts:


TSB is nobody’s local bank

I’m one of the people who’s been “bumped” from Lloyd’s Bank to the new TSB, a spin-off set up because the EU decided that Lloyds/TSB was too big after getting a government subsidy. The bit that’s now being branded TSB was going to be sold to the Co-Operative Bank, but they pulled out because they have financial trouble of their own. The new branding appeared on a number of Lloyds/TSB and Cheltenham and Gloucester branches last Monday, along with an advertising campaign trumpeting their return to “local banking”. These include adverts at railway stations like the one below (there was a similar one at Vauxhall, the first station out), which reads “Hello Waterloo, welcome back to local banking”.

A large advertisement from the TSB bank at a railway station, reading "Hello Waterloo, welcome back to local banking"

Continue reading

Possibly Related Posts:


Why do you believe her?

Last Tuesday a British soap actor, Michael “Le Vell” Turner, was found not guilty of multiple counts of rape and sexual assault on a child (now 17). There has been some suggestions that his prosecution was part of a “celebrity witch-hunt” in the wake of the Jimmy Savile scandal, something the prosecution service denies. In the wake of the acquittal, my Twitter feed became full of tweets tagged “#ibelieveher”, a tag that first became popular after the conviction of the footballer Ched Evans, whose victim was named on Twitter and accused of being a liar by some of his friends and fans. There was a useful article by Glosswitch about the reaction, which I found linked from this tweet:

Continue reading

Possibly Related Posts:


Apple needs more than a cheap phone to wipe out Android

A Galaxy Nexus, a Nexus 4 and a Nexus 7 side by side

iPhone 5C: if Apple produces a cheap phone, it could wipe out its rivals

Mic Wright (@brokenbottleboy on Twitter) says that if Apple launches a cheap iPhone tonight (the rumoured iPhone 5C), it could do serious damage to both Android and the new Microsoft-owned Nokia handset business:

It wants to produce a phone that is rugged enough to appeal to African consumers, modern enough for tech-savvy Chinese buyers and cheap enough to capture even more market share in Western markets.

If we do see the “iPhone 5C” tonight – and I do think it’s a strong bet – it will be a major headache for Android phone makers of all stripes and the newly minted Mokia (Microsoft + Nokia) alliance. Apple’s big gap in iPhone dominance is the lower end of the market where cheap phones available free on contract from day one are keeping Nokia and the less high-end Android models afloat. Samsung is ably battling and often beating Apple in the premium market but if Apple launches a compelling iPhone that can be offered free-on-contract and for a very, very low unlocked price, it will run the table.

Continue reading

Possibly Related Posts:


Ariel Castro’s suicide is no tragedy

Ohio captor ‘needed suicide watch’: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-23967581

Ariel Castro, the man who kept three young women captive in his house in Ohio for several years, was found hanged in his cell on Tuesday. According to the above news report:

The prosecutor who tried Castro called him a “coward” unable to withstand “a small portion” of what he had inflicted.

But Mr Weintraub told Cleveland newspaper the Plain Dealer: “He’s still a human being. This is still a civilised society.”

Continue reading

Possibly Related Posts:


Issy Stapleton: suspicious timing

Picture of a young girl in a red sweater holding a black cat Recently a mother who was known to the online autism community and kept a blog about parenting her autistic daughter was found in a fume-filled van with her. Both the mother, Kelli Stapleton, and her daughter Issy are alive, although Issy may have sustained permanent brain damage. The mother is facing an attempted murder charge and possible life imprisonment.

In every such case, there is an outpouring of support for the parent who killed or injured their child and the assumption that they must have done it because of the stress of parenting an autistic child and the lack of support. It is the only circumstance in which the killing of a child by an adult elicits any sympathy for the perpetrator. One very suspicious aspect of this incident that should be emphasised in all this is the timing: the day her mother tried to kill her, she recorded that Issy had returned home from a residential treatment programme of some kind, where she’d been for about six months.

http://thestatuswoe.wordpress.com/2013/09/03/she-is-home/

Also the same day, Kelli (the mother) posted the “power player” article, about how her school’s special needs teacher refused to cooperate with her support plan:

http://thestatuswoe.wordpress.com/2013/09/03/when-a-power-player-takes-you-down/

All this must have happened in a very short space of time, so anyone who wants to portray Kelli Stapleton as a “stressed autism mom” needs to explain how she got stressed enough to try to kill her daughter in a matter of a day or so.

I should add that I’ve been in a special school where there were boys who were prone to violence at very trivial provocations, such as a refused demand or not liking someone’s tone of voice. There were a couple of incidents of people threatening others with knives while I was there, but no killings in the whole history of the place, and some of us were in considerably more vulnerable positions than these parents. And if I had done any such thing, I would have been sent to a secure home or young offenders’ institution. We should not be so quick to jump to a sympathetic position when the killer or attacker is a parent.

Possibly Related Posts:


Ukraine and Drugs: the vapidity of Stacey Dooley

Picture of Stacey Dooley, a young white woman with light brown hair, talking to a customs officer in OdessaEurope’s Dirty Drug Secret: Stacey Dooley Investigates (viewable in the UK until next Sunday)

Last Monday I saw a programme featuring Stacey Dooley, the British “investigative journalist” whose efforts at understanding the divisions in Luton and the origins of the English Defence League I previously reviewed here. Every time Dooley is on TV, the hits I get for that entry make a huge jump, and last week it was the single most viewed entry on this blog, and so I thought I’d better watch her latest effort, an investigation into the smuggling of drugs such as cocaine through Ukraine into western Europe. She also looked at the effects of home-made drugs on poor people in Ukraine, who cannot afford imported cocaine; the two principal home-made concoctions are said to result in permanent brain damage in one case and a two-year life expectancy in the other for users. As in previous reports by her, there is too much emphasis on her personal reactions to the situations she encounters, and her remarks are often vapid and sometimes downright inappropriate.

Continue reading

Possibly Related Posts:


Parliament got it right on Syria (for now)

Picture of a man holding a banner saying 'Dear free world, enjoy watching us burn', with a picture of several dead bodies from the recent chemical attacks.Last Thursday, the British Parliament resoundingly defeated a government motion to join military action in Syria in response to the recent chemical weapon attacks in the suburbs of Damascus. Labour were joined in their opposition by a large number of Tory MPs, and it led to David Cameron blaming Tony Blair for “poisoning the well” of public opinion against British involvement in such actions. He may be partly right but as I have said before, British public opinion has supported more recent military action in support of Arab Spring uprisings such as in Libya. Syria is different, both politically and geographically, and this situation has all the warning signs of the kind of costly, long-term military entanglement that the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan proved to be, which the British public understandably have no appetite for.

Continue reading

Possibly Related Posts:


Don’t mind the monkeys

A still from the BBC's Winterbourne View Panorama documentary, showing a male care worker standing over a male patient who is stuck under a chair, while another man sits on the chair.Carers and care workers are the best kind of people. So why are they treated so disgracefully?

Yesterday the Guardian published the above article by Rhiannon Lucy Cosslett, best known for co-founding Vagenda magazine and for a column in the New Statesman, which romanticised the role of carers both paid and unpaid. She has a brother who is autistic and has learning disabilities, and recently one of his carers had to resign because her relationship ended and she could not afford to live by herself on a carer’s wages, so had to go and live with her parents a long way away. She called carers “the best kind of people”, doing an often unpleasant job for little money or a small sum in benefits. This provoked quite a bit of debate on Twitter among people who had both been carers and those who needed their care. The general consensus was that calling them “the best people” was not only far too simplistic but also patronising, serving to cover up low pay and stress among the carers themselves and abuse of the people who receive care.

Continue reading

Possibly Related Posts:


Muslims must pay to save Academy

Recently I saw a number of appeals on Facebook and other social media to sign a petition to save a “mosque” in Manchester, the Islamic Academy of Manchester, which had been sold to a property developer and is likely to be converted into flats by a specialist church conversion firm. The building had been owned by the council which leased part of it to a Muslim organisation, but the lease has expired and the building sold. The academy’s website has a press release and an article calling for “urgent action”, including contacting the media to protest “misrepresentations” and putting forward objections to the new owners’ planning application, but one kind of action is conspicuously missing.

Continue reading

Possibly Related Posts:


‘Road tax’ and the state of the A1

The BBC’s online “Magazine” last week published three articles about transport issues, one of them about the notion of “road tax” and how it’s commonly used as a trump card in arguments between motorists and cyclists, and two about various major road and railway projects and how likely they are to happen. One of those is a bridge or tunnel across from the mainland to the Isle of Wight, which despite being right next to three small cities on the south coast is linked to it only by ferries; another is a motorway running northwards through eastern England, such as an extension of the M11 or an upgrade of most or all of the A1 to motorway. Having been up the A1 quite recently, I can agree that parts of it badly need upgrading, but not the parts that are commonly assumed.

Continue reading

Possibly Related Posts:


Benefits Britain 1949: yes, the world has changed since then

A light brown-skinned woman with braided hair, wearing a red jumper and a black top under it, holding a crutch in her hand, getting out of a metallic grey Nissan carCurrently Channel 4 is running a series called Benefits Britain 1949, in which people are invited to live on benefits at 1949 levels (supposedly adjusted to inflation) for a week. The Daily Mail has published an article by Melissa Kite in which it is declared that this “extraordinary experiment … PROVES the welfare state has lost its way”. The three people featured are a 54-year-old grandmother who it claims is “smartly dressed in fashionable clothes, jewellery and sports an immaculate manicure”, a 24-year-old man with spina bifida who uses a wheelchair, and a 71-year-old widower, all from Nottingham where, she says “half the population is on some kind of benefit. Yes, half”. The experiment sees the disabled man get his “first real job” while the pensioner is packed off to an old people’s home.

Continue reading

Possibly Related Posts:


No, it’s not fascism

Recently there has been some well-deserved condemnation on blogs and Twitter feeds that I read about the British government’s attacks on immigration, which took the form of vans telling people who are in the country illegally to “go home or face arrest”, as well as spot checks on people coming through certain London train stations, in which UKBA (UK Border Agency) officers were observed to be stopping non-white travellers. This has led to some to declare that the UK is sinking into fascism, which seems to be based on ignorance of what fascism really is.

Continue reading

Possibly Related Posts:


Twitter silence is not an answer

Drawing of Jane AustenRecently in the UK (not sure how many of my overseas readers are aware of it) there has been a major controversy about abuse of women activists on Twitter, which erupted when a feminist campaigner was targeted with threats of rape after her campaign to get a woman’s face (Jane Austen’s) on a UK banknote, as that of Elizabeth Fry, a 19th-century prison reformer, is about to disappear from them. Three others — historian Mary Beard, MP Stella Creasy and journalist Hadley Freeman — all subsequently reported that they had received either rape threats or bomb threats, and it was suggested, I believe by the Times columnist Caitlin Moran, that we all stay off Twitter last Sunday as some sort of protest because the site does not have an “abuse” button in the same way it has a “spam” button. There are two major objections to this reaction: one is that many people rely on social media, including Twitter, for any kind of social life, the other that it is a cave-in to the bullies.

Continue reading

Possibly Related Posts:


Justice for Jenny: delivered

Picture of Jenny Hatch in between her friends Kelly Morris and Jim Talbert. Morris is wearing a black short-sleeved top with white trouses, Jenny a multi-coloured, horizontally-striped, knee-length dress and Talbert a grey suit jacket with black trousersWoman with Down syndrome prevails over parents in guardianship case (from the Washington Post website)

Yesterday Jenny Hatch, who had been fighting to free herself from a restrictive guardianship arrangement which required her to live in a group home against her wishes, won her case (see earlier entry). Jenny (officially Margaret Jean Hatch) had lived in the community in Hampton, Virginia, until last year when a bicycle accident meant she had to seek medical care, and although her friends were willing for her to live with them (and had been employing them in their thrift store, which is a kind of second-hand shop for British readers), they were under the impression that she could not get a Medicaid waiver (an allowance for free healthcare) unless she was in a group home. Shortly afterwards, her parents filed for legal guardianship and she was forced to live in group homes while the proceedings were ongoing. Her mother was awarded temporary guardianship in February. Yesterday that was quashed; temporary guardianship was awarded to her friends, Jim Talbert and Kelly Morris, for a year with the expectation that she will be released from any such arrangement after that. There are two local TV news reports here and an earlier Washington Post report here.

Continue reading

Possibly Related Posts:


Young people’s mental health: failed by the system

Picture of Jonny Benjamin, a white man with stubble in a thick blue jacket with a furry collarBBC Three: Failed by the NHS

Last night there was a documentary on BBC Three about young people whose mental health conditions went untreated for months or years by the NHS mental health services, including in cases where they were experiencing severe psychosis and were at risk of killing themselves. The programme was part of the same “It’s a Mad World” season as Don’t Call Me Crazy, which I reviewed here three weeks ago, and the presenter, Jonny Benjamin, suffers from schizoaffective disorder and has been running a YouTube channel about his conditions (he also has Crohn’s disease) for three years and works for a TV production company (he is interviewed by Mind’s Time to Change here). As great as this documentary was, the title feeds into a media culture of blaming “the NHS” for things that are wrong with the health system, and plays into the hands of those who want to destroy or privatise it.

Continue reading

Possibly Related Posts: