Linux Format issue 76 (Feb 2006) has just been released in the UK. On page 32 is a round-up of the spreadsheets available for Linux, namely Gnumeric, PlanMaker, OpenOffice.org Calc, ThinkFree Office Calc and KSpread. The last (version 1.4.2) receives a score of 1 out of 10, and labelled "a disaster area that needs some serious work to even be considered". The review highlights the lack of macros and filters ("you're better off looking inside the nearest coffee machine"), and says that it has the bare minimum of spreadsheet functionality but nothing else, and that the stock SUSE 10 build of KSpread "steadfastly refused to create any charts whatsoever":
Select your data, click the Chart button, monkey around in the Create Chart dialog, then bang! it crashes. What kind of spreadsheet can't do charts? A rubbish spreadsheet, that's what kind.
Top score went to OpenOffice.org Calc, with 9 out of 10. Commercial contenders ThinkFree and Planmaker also scored badly, with 3 and 5 out of 10 respectively. On page 26, the magazine gives 7 out of 10 to KDE 3.5 itself, calling it "an excellent release, marred by the feeling that KDE is missing genuine innovation". Attention is drawn to new features, and ACID2 compiliance, in Konqueror, webcam support in Kopete, SuperKaramba and improvements in the Kicker.